A new study finds a wide gap between what HR leaders think recognition delivers and what employees actually feel.
By Gillian Manning
Organizations are investing in recognition programs, but employees aren’t convinced they’re working for their needs. Just 32% of employees say their company’s rewards deliver what’s important to them, compared with 54% of the HR leaders who design those programs, according to a new study from employee recognition firm Xceleration.
The 2026 Recognition Disconnect study surveyed 686 U.S. full-time employees and people leaders in June 2026, asking both groups identical questions. The gap held across every measure tested. HR leaders were more likely to say recognition is tied to contribution (67% versus 42%) and that it feels personal (57% versus 38%).
Ben Levenbaum, CEO of Xceleration, says, “We wanted to know if what leaders believe they’re delivering actually matches what employees experience. Leaders can see everything about how a program runs, the budget, the participation, the awards handed out, and almost nothing about whether any single one of those rewards actually resonated with the person who got it. That blind spot is often the difference between a top performer staying and a top performer leaving.”
Addressing that blind spot is a timely concern. Fifty-one percent of employees show strong signs of burnout, and 42% say AI-related pressure is significantly affecting them. Only about 3 in 10 report regularly get time to disconnect and recover.
When it comes to rewards, cash is still king. Cash wins in a head-to-head test, with 68% of employees choosing a $5,000 payout over any alternative. But 76% ranked rest, recovery, or time with loved ones among their top priorities for a meaningful reward.
Among those who passed on the cash, individual, family-inclusive travel was the top non-cash pick (36%). Seventy percent of employees rate individual travel highly, versus 46% for group trips and President’s Club-style programs. The most burned out employees were even more drawn to travel, at 64% compared with 51% of other survey respondents.
The survey also found that:
- employees who received the fullest, most personalized top-performer recognition were far more likely to say they plan to stay than those who got generic or no recognition (82% versus 52%);
- HR and sales leaders value being recognized as a whole person just as much as financial incentives like equity when deciding to stay with a company, but 1 in 3 feel their own families are rarely or never included in that recognition; and
- employees who are recognized are far more intent on staying at their jobs than those who have not ever been recognized (70% versus 41%).
Looking to dive deeper? We keep an ever-growing archive of HRO Today Association member webinars. Watch now: “Pay Transparency: Clear Opportunity or Visible Challenge?”
