Screening & Selection

2024 Baker’s Dozen Customer Satisfaction Ratings: Pre-Employment Screening

We rank the top providers of pre-employment screening services based on customer satisfaction surveys. 

By The Editors

HRO Today’s Baker’s Dozen Customer Satisfaction Ratings™ are based solely on feedback from buyers of the rated services; the ratings are not based on the opinion of the HRO Today staff. We collect feedback annually through an online survey, which we distribute to buyers directly through our own mailing lists and indirectly through service providers. Once collected, response data for all providers with a statistically significant sample size are loaded into the HRO Today database for analysis.

In order to determine an overall ranking from this data, we analyze results across three subcategories: service breadth, deal sizes, and service quality. Using a predetermined algorithm that weighs questions and categories based on importance, we calculate scores in all three subcategories as well as an overall score. These scores are the basis of the Baker’s Dozen Customer Satisfaction Ratings™ and demonstrate the relative differences among the ranked service providers.

For the midsize program pre-employment screening list, methodology was based upon ranking on size of deal first and then overall score. A provider that was above 13 on the size of deal ranking but did not make the enterprise list was moved down in order to the top of the midsize program providers list so there was no overlap.

The only influence that HRO Today has on the outcome of this survey is that HRO Today discards incomplete surveys or surveys outside the normal distribution. This includes surveys that are too perfect as to be possible or so negative that they are spiteful and inaccurate. Otherwise, HRO Today has no impact on the survey outcome. While we do not claim that our methodology is the only viable ratings program available, we do vouch for its statistical validity. We hope the Baker’s Dozen Customer Satisfaction Ratings™ provides insight into your next RFP process.

View Live Baker’s Dozen Announcement

Overall Enterprise Pre-Employment Screening Leaders

  1. MBI Worldwide Background Checks and Drug Screening
  2. Universal Background Screening
  3. Peopletrail
  4. CNet Technologies
  5. Cisive
  6. JDP
  7. AccuSourceHR
  8. CICheckedâ„¢, formerly Commercial Investigations
  9. Edge Information Management
  10. Data Facts Inc.
  11. Verified Credentials, LLC
  12. Alliance Background
  13. Validity Screening Solutions

Enterprise Breadth of Service Leaders

  1. CNet Technologies
  2. Universal Background Screening
  3. Cisive
  4. Edge Information Management
  5. Data Facts Inc.
  6. MBI Worldwide Background Checks and Drug Screening
  7. Peopletrail
  8. CICheckedâ„¢, formerly Commercial Investigations
  9. Verified Credentials, LLC
  10. AccuSourceHR
  11. Validity Screening Solutions
  12. JDP
  13. Alliance Background

Enterprise Size of Deals Leaders

  1. JDP
  2. Cisive
  3. Universal Background Screening
  4. AccuSourceHR
  5. MBI Worldwide Background Checks and Drug Screening
  6. CNet Technologies
  7. Peopletrail
  8. Data Facts Inc.
  9. Edge Information Management
  10. CICheckedâ„¢, formerly Commercial Investigations
  11. Alliance Background
  12. Verified Credentials, LLC
  13. Validity Screening Solutions

Enterprise Quality of Service Leaders

  1. MBI Worldwide Background Checks and Drug Screening
  2. Peopletrail
  3. Universal Background Screening
  4. CNet Technologies
  5. Cisive
  6. JDP
  7. AccuSourceHR
  8. CICheckedâ„¢, formerly Commercial Investigations
  9. Edge Information Management
  10. Data Facts Inc.
  11. Verified Credentials, LLC
  12. Alliance Background
  13. Validity Screening Solutions

Overall Midsize Program Leaders

  1. SmartHRCheqs, an Alliance Risk Group company
  2. Backgrounds Online
  3. Verified First
  4. CredentialCheck
  5. DISA
  6. IntelliCorp
  7. PlusOne Screening Solutions
  8. One Source The Background Check Company
  9. ClearStar

Midsize Program Breadth of Service Leaders

  1. DISA
  2. CredentialCheck
  3. SmartHRCheqs, an Alliance Risk Group company
  4. IntelliCorp
  5. Backgrounds Online
  6. Verified First
  7. PlusOne Screening Solutions
  8. ClearStar
  9. One Source The Background Check Company

Midsize Program Size of Deals Leaders

  1. DISA
  2. IntelliCorp
  3. ClearStar
  4. Verified First
  5. CredentialCheck
  6. SmartHRCheqs, an Alliance Risk Group company
  7. Backgrounds Online
  8. PlusOne Screening Solutions
  9. One Source The Background Check Company

Midsize Program Quality of Service Leaders

  1. Backgrounds Online
  2. SmartHRCheqs, an Alliance Risk Group company
  3. Verified First
  4. CredentialCheck
  5. DISA
  6. IntelliCorp
  7. PlusOne Screening Solutions
  8. One Source The Background Check Company
  9. ClearStar
Tags: Baker's Dozen, November 2024

Recent Articles